Sunday, March 6, 2016

Grief and Loss - A Buddhist Parable

Grief at the loss of a loved one is not a competitive sport, but we frequently subscribe to popular perceptions that some losses are deeper than others – a friend’s loss is deeper than losing a pet; a parent over a friend; a spouse over a parent.  And all of these losses pale compared to the pain of the loss of a child.

Maybe that’s why the story of Kisa Gotami rings through the centuries to bring us to understand grief and loss in the hard, but liberating light of impermanence and the universality of suffering and death.

The First Noble Truth in the Buddha’s very first teaching since his awakening spells this out clearly:

…the noble truth of suffering—birth is suffering, old age is suffering, sickness is suffering, death is suffering.

Suffering is a common bond that we all share.  The word “suffering” in the Pali language of the earliest Buddhist texts is dukka, meaning the suffering that comes from being incapable of being satisfied.  But when we lose someone we love—maybe a child in particular—the meaning of our suffering comes right out of the dictionary’s definition:  the state of pain, distress, or hardship.  It is nobody’s preferred state of mind or being.

So it was with Kisa Gotami, a young woman who lived during the Buddha’s lifetime, and who gave birth to a son.  Her happiness was shattered when the infant sickened and died.  Her grief was so overwhelming, she refused to believe her beautiful baby boy was dead.  She carried his dead body with her, asking her neighbors how to resuscitate him.  The sight of her horrified her neighbors, who saw her becoming deranged with her grief.  They advised her to accept her son’s death and make his funeral arrangements.  But Kisa Gotami kept begging her baby boy to wake up.

An elder in the village finally took compassion on her suffering saying, “We can’t help you—but there is a great teacher near by, a Buddha.  Perhaps he can bring your son back to you.”

In great haste and excitement, Kisa Gotami went to find the teacher, clutching her dead child.  Who of us would not do the same—seek out the second opinion, do whatever it took to bring our beloved back to us again? Kisa Gotami used the words of desperate hope when she found the Buddha and asked him to revive her child:  I will do anything to bring my son back.

The Buddha saw her desperation and probably her madness as well, and said:  “Find me a mustard seed—from a home where no one has ever lost someone to death.  Bring the seed back to me, and your son will be restored to life.”

Kisa Gotami took her dead child and went to find mustard seed from a home where there had been no death.  Mustard seed in the India of those times was as common as table salt is in ours and even less expensive.  Everyone she met was willing to give her mustard seeds, but everyone had lost a grandmother, a husband, an aunt, even a child, to death.

It took some time before Kisa Gotami’s wild hope turned to the quiet realization:  no one is spared death; it is an inevitable and natural part of life, and pain and the suffering of loss is just as natural a part of the survivors’ lives too.

Putting aside her grief, Kisa Gotami prepared her son for burial and then returned to the Buddha to become his disciple.

In a poetic interpretation of this return meeting between the Buddha and Kisa Gotami, the Buddha says:

Seeing one dead, know for sure:  ‘I shall never see him in this existence’.  And just as the fire of a burning house is quenched, so does the contemplative wise person scatter grief’s power… He who would seeks peace should pull out the arrow of lamentation, useless longings, and the self-made pangs of grief.  He who has removed this unwholesome arrow and has calmed himself will obtain peace of mind.

And Kisa Gotami can now respond:

I’ve cut out the arrow,
put down the burden,
done the task.
I, Kisa Gotami,
my heart well-released,
have said this.

It is not one of those  “and they lived happily ever after” stories.  It is not a miracle story of the dead returned to life.  The Buddha didn’t perform miracles or tell happily ever after stories.  He assigned a practice, a job, a task.  In performing that practice or job, that task, what unfolded before you was the clear vision of truth, life as it truly is, not life through the clouded eyes of seeing what you wanted to see.


Death is inevitable; the sharp arrow of grief and loss shoots straight through us who are left behind.  Our job must be to remove the second arrow, the suffering of denial, wishful thinking, groundless hope.  In the middle of our lives, for all its sorrows and suffering, there is still a way to free ourselves from our grief—when we see it as part of our life and see it in the lives of everyone around us as well.  We are not alone, not even in the terrible grief of a terrible loss.  We share that with our fellow beings who, like Kisa Gotami, like her neighbors, have been on the path before us.

No comments:

Post a Comment